The Pennsylvania District Attorney and gun rights activists have filed a federal court lawsuit seeking to overturn a ban that prevents medical marijuana patients from purchasing and possessing firearms. This is the latest legal challenge to the policy.
Robert Greene of Warren County, Pennsylvania, a District Attorney who is a registered medical marijuana patient in Pennsylvania, teamed with the Second Amendment Foundation to file a lawsuit against the federal government at the U.S. District Court of the Western District of Pennsylvania, on Tuesday.
The U.S. Supreme Court is currently considering whether to take up the question of the constitutionality of the federal gun prohibition for marijuana users.
In the new lawsuit, the U.S. Attorney-General Merrick Garland, along with the FBI and Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco, Firearms and Explosives, (ATF) heads, are named as defendants. The lead plaintiff’s attorney believes that this is the first civil challenge, and not criminal, to the federal statute.
Greene’s involvement in the case was particularly notable. Greene’s participation in the case is particularly notable.
Late last month, the prosecutor declared that he would not seek reelection. Instead, he would focus on advocating for medical cannabis patient’s rights.
The civil suit, This, is different from the previous court cases that challenged the constitutionality of gun laws for plaintiffs that were criminally charged. “You’re facing a challenge for people who are simply asserting that the prohibition is unconstitutional on its face, or as applied, ‘as applied,’ meaning only to them,” Adam Kraut said on Tuesday, the lead attorney of the plaintiff and executive Director of SAF.
He said, “I hope that not only will we win our lawsuit but it will also inspire the federal Congress into action to solve this problem, because millions of Americans are being denied their Second Amendment rights and forced to decide between using medical marijuana to treat their symptoms or exercising their constitutionally protected right.” “That is not acceptable.”
SAF has joined Warren County District Attorney Robert Greene in challenging 922(g)(3)’s prohibition on the possession of firearms and ammunition by medical marijuana card holders.https://t.co/8rFYseVfKM pic.twitter.com/LtUTaVgFtk
The SAF (@2AFDN 23 January 2024
The Congressional Research Service (CRS), meanwhile, recently pointed out that three cases are currently being considered by the nation’s top court which could settle the issue of guns and cannabis.
The Supreme Court is expected to decide if they will hear the federal government’s appeal of a Circuit Court ruling which found that the firearm restriction violated the Second Amendment.
The DOJ appeals the ruling of the U.S. Court of Appeals, Fifth Circuit . This court examined Section 922g)(3) of the federal law that prohibits “unlawful users” of illegal drugs from purchasing or possessing firearms. The court ruled that the policy was unconstitutional when it applied to a man convicted for using cannabis while in possession a firearm.
Multiple courts have weighed in on the issue, forcing Justice Department to defend its statute amid challenges from across the nation. The Fifth Circuit, which covers jurisdictions in Mississippi Louisiana and Texas, is the highest court that has ruled against this ban.
In most cases, and in this latest civil lawsuit, the key legal argument against gun control is based on a reading of a previous Supreme Court decision, which ruled that restrictions should be consistent with the historic context of 1791’s Second Amendment ratification. The federal statute was challenged by those who argued there is no historical analogy, but the DOJ maintained that the historical laws that prohibited guns for certain groups such as the mentally sick and the habitually intoxicated justified its enforcement.
The prosecution of President Joe Biden’s son Hunter Biden has drawn public attention to section 922(g). Hunter Biden has been charged for owning a firearm while admitting that he used crack cocaine illegally years ago.
Hunter Biden’s attorneys recently asked the U.S. District Court for Delaware to dismiss the case. They argued that prosecutors were applying an unconstitutional law that, if widely enforced, would criminalize thousands of marijuana users who are in compliance with state laws.
The Biden administration claimed that cannabis consumers with guns pose a unique danger to society. This is because they are “unlikely” to store their weapon properly. The Biden administration claimed that cannabis consumers who own guns are a special danger to society. This is because they are “unlikely to” store their weapons properly.
Federal government officials have repeatedly stated that historical precedents support the idea of limiting firearm rights for cannabis consumers. But a number of federal courts have ruled the marijuana-related prohibition unconstitutional . This has led DOJ to appeal several ongoing cases.
In October, the Justice Department made similar arguments during oral argument in a related but separate case before the U.S. Court of Appeals Eleventh Circuit. This case is about the Second Amendment rights for medical cannabis patients in Florida.
The U.S. District Court for the Western District of Oklahoma ruled last summer that the prohibition on people using marijuana possessing firearms was unconstitutional. The judge stated that the federal government’s justification for maintaining the law was “concerning.”
In U.S. District Court for the Western District of Texas, a judge ruled last April that banning people who use marijuana from possessing firearms is unconstitutional–and it said the same legal principle also applies to the sale and transfer of guns.
The U.S. Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco, Firearms and Explosives sent a letter in August to Arkansas officials stating that the recently passed law allowing medical cannabis patients to get concealed carry gun permits, “creates unacceptable risks” and could compromise the state’s federally approved alternative weapon licensing policy.
issued a warning shortly after Minnesota’s Governor signed the legalization bill in law. The agency reminded that cannabis users are prohibited from purchasing or possessing firearms and ammunition until federal prohibition is lifted.
ATF will issue an advisory in 2020 that specifically targets Michigan and requires gun sellers conduct federal background checks for all unlicensed buyers. It said Michigan’s cannabis laws allowed “habitual marijuana consumers” and other disqualified persons to obtain firearms without a license.
A little-noticed FBI memo from 2019, which recently surfaced, shows that the federal government generally does not view it as a crime for medical cannabis caregivers or growers to own guns .
—
Marijuana Moment tracks more than 1,000 cannabis and drug policy bills that have been introduced in state legislatures, and Congress. Patreon supporters who pledge at least $25/month gain access to our interactive charts, maps and hearing calendar.
Discover more about our marijuana bills tracker. Become a Patreon supporter to gain access.
—
The South Dakota House of Representatives passed two bills this month to inform patients of the federal restrictions for marijuana users on firearm ownership. The first bill would require medical cannabis patients to include a warning about the federal gun ban in their applications. The second would require dispensaries to post informational signs on site and fine businesses who don’t comply.
Colorado activists have proposed a ballot initiative for 2024 that would permit marijuana users to carry concealed guns.
Florida Gov. Ron DeSantis, a former agriculture commissioner who is one of those who have challenged the ban in court, said last week that believes this restriction violates Second Amendment.
Two Republican members of Congress have introduced two bills in this session, focusing on marijuana and gun policy.
Rep. Brian Mast, co-chairman of the Congressional Cannabis Caucus and a member of the House of Representatives, introduced legislation in May last year to protect the Second Amendment right of marijuana users who live in states where the drug is legal. This would allow them to buy and possess firearms, which they are currently prohibited to have under federal law.
Senate Majority leader Chuck Schumer (DNY) has promised to attach that legislation to the bipartisan marijuana banking Bill, which advanced out of Committee last year and awaits floor action.
Mast is also sponsoring a separate Bill from Rep. Alex Mooney (R-WV), in this session, which would allow medical marijuana patients to buy and possess firearms.
Massachusetts Marijuana Sales Set Record in December with Total Purchases Reaching $1.8 billion
The article Pennsylvania District attorney Sues Federal Government over Gun Ban for Medical Marijuana patients first appeared on Marijuana moment.
